Well I was thinking, since it exists a Michelin(don't know if it is spelled right at all)guide for restaurants that we could make a similar guide with animes/mangas. A guide where we list animes/mangas by giving them a score in stars. And if the list becomes good maybe the mods can put it on the site or something.

well here is how i think the pointing should be:

1 star = Steer away, this is anime/manga at the worst.
2 stars = Waste of time
3 stars = okey. Not good, not bad
4 stars = Pretty good. Very good and entertaning at times, but something is bad or missing
5 stars = Good, worth watching. A entertaining serie, but misses that little extra to be a classic.
6 stars = Awesome! a classic. This is anime/manga at it's very best. Legendary

well this is my list of the things I have read or watched:

6 stars:
Love Hina (Manga & anime)
Naruto (anime)
AMG (manga & anime)
Dragonball Z (anime)

5 stars:
FMA(anime)
FMP(anime)
Onegai teacher(anime)
Kimi Ga Nozomu Eien(anime)
Bleach (anime)

4 stars:
Tenjou Tenge (anime & manga)
Ichigo 100% (anime)
Ai Yori Aoshi (anime)

Strawberry Panic (anime)

3 stars:
Green green (anime)
Dragonball GT (anime)

please comment if you disagree with my list, and make one yourselves.

Well I hope so many posts, so we will get a long list in the end.

Splendid idea with this list and stars. Though I have the different sentence what to some anime and mang. This is my list mang and anime which I read and watched:

6 stars:
Ah My Goddess (manga & anime)
Kamikaze kaito Jeanne (manga & anime)
Inuysaha(manga & anime)
Sailor Moon(anime)

5 stars:
Full Metal Ppanic(anime)
Onegai teacher(anime)
Love Hina (Manga & anime)
Naruto (anime)

4 stars
Chobits(anime)
Magic knight Rayearth(anime)
Air(anime)

3 stars:
Tokio Mew Mew(anime)

As if there would be any doubt that AMG would get 6 stars considering what this site is :p

6 Stars:
~None, I have yet to see an anime that would deserve this rating

5 Stars:
Blood+ (Anime)
Bleach (Anime)

4 Stars:
Tsubasa Chronicle (Anime)
Ah! My Goddess (Anime)
Negima (Anime)

3 stars:
Inu Yasha (Anime)
Love Hina (Anime)

I have a lot more to add later, I just have to go through my list and remember everything i've watched.

6 stars:
gantz
macross zero
air
my neighbor totoro
FFVII Advent Children

5 stars:
tsubasa
bleach
crest of the stars
last exile
madlax
earth girl arjuna


4 stars:
Eureka seveN
yukikaze
Azumanga Daioh
grave of the fireflies
kenshin
Sol_Bianca_the_Legacy
tenchi
Saiyuki reloaded
gundam

could go on but too many to list/ think aboutX|

I can't do this guide with my 200 anime8( !!!!
Long time for check a give them a result

@Viet:

If you have seen the animes we have listed you could give them your ratings and reccomend your favorites ^_^

well this is mine :P [i havent seen alot but thats my list]

6 stars:
Ah! My Goddess! Tv
DragonBall Z
Golden Boy
Love Hina

4 Stars
Inuyasha
Negima
Street Fighter 2

here mine (have more just have to remember them) =0

6 stars:
not yet.

5 stars:
ah my goddess/Aa megami sama
fruit basket
naruto
pita ten
W.I.T.C.H

4 stars:
avatar the last airbender
mew mew power /tokyo mew mew
aliennine emulators
sister princess
code:lyoko
vandread
digimon
my neighbor totoro
kiki's delivery service
galaxy angel

3 stars:
inuyasha
negima
love hina
mermaid melody
street fighter
he is my master
to heart 2

2 stars:
dragon ball z